8 tasty Pirate Themed Food Ideas (perfect for a pirate party)

Sharing is caring!

Do you need some ideas on what food to serve for a pirate themed party? Well, we’ve got some ideas that are sure to be a hit at your child’s pirate party. (And adults could enjoy them too.)

pirate party food ideas

1. Pirate Ship Sandwiches

Pirate sandwiches (generated by DALL-E)

These adorable mini pirate ships are as fun to make as they are to eat. Do they look exactly like pirate ships? No! But kids have a great imagination.

What you need:

  • Hoagie rolls or sub sandwiches
  • Pretzel sticks or toothpicks
  • Paper or printed pirate flags

How to make them:

  1. Cut your sandwich rolls in half.
  2. Fill them with your kiddo’s favorite sandwich fillings.
  3. Stick a pretzel or toothpick “mast” into each half.
  4. Attach a small paper sail or pirate flag to the mast.

Now you’ve got a fleet of tasty pirate ships that are perfect for small hands and big imaginations.





2. ???? Cannonball Meatballs

Fire the cannons! These “cannonballs” are sure to be a direct hit with your little pirates.

What you need:

  • Meatballs (homemade or store-bought)
  • Marinara or BBQ sauce for dipping

Serving tip: Place the meatballs in a big bowl labeled “Cannonballs” and put the dipping sauce in smaller bowls nearby. Kids will love the idea of eating pirate ammunition!




3. Treasure Chest Nuggets

Adorox 24 Pack Treasure Chest Treat Boxes Pirate Birthday Party Favor Goodies

X marks the spot with these golden nuggets of deliciousness.

What you need:

  • Chicken nuggets or fish sticks
  • Small boxes or containers that look like treasure chests (similar to the ones above)
  • waxed deli paper sheets to line the boxes (like the paper below)

GeeRic Waxed Deli Paper Sheets 12 * 12 Inch, 100 Pcs Food Basket Liners for Sandwiches, Burgers, Checkered Deli Wrap Wax Paper Sheets Black

How to serve:

  1. Cook the nuggets or fish sticks according to the package instructions.
  2. Place them in your wax paper-lined “treasure chest” containers.
  3. Label them as “Golden Nuggets” or “Treasure Chest Treats.”

Kids will feel like they’ve struck gold when they open these tasty treasure chests!




4. ???? Gold Coin Cookies

Avast ye! These sweet coins are perfect for any pirate’s bounty.

What you need:

  • Round sugar cookies
  • Gold foil or gold-colored sprinkles

How to make them:

  1. Bake or buy round sugar cookies.
  2. Either wrap them in gold foil or decorate them with gold-colored sprinkles.
  3. Arrange them in small piles like stacks of gold coins.

These shimmering treats will make your little pirates feel rich with treasure!



5. ???? Pirate Punch

Quench your crew’s thirst with this fun and fruity pirate brew.

What you need:

  • Fruit punch or blue raspberry drink
  • Ice cube tray
  • Gummy sharks or pirate-themed candies

How to prepare:

  1. The night before, freeze gummy sharks or pirate candies in ice cube trays with water.
  2. On party day, pour your chosen drink into a large bowl or pitcher.
  3. Add your special pirate ice cubes.

Watch your young buccaneers’ eyes light up as they discover the hidden treasures in their drinks!


Related Article: Non-alcoholic mocktails that are proven party favorites.





6. Pirate Map Pizzas

Pirate map pizzas (Photo generated by DALL-E)

Most kids love pizza, and mini things, so why not make them some mini pizzas that are decorated to look like pirate maps.

Because this requires the stove, this will need you – the adult – to bake the pizzas.

What you need:

  • Mini pizza bases or English muffins
  • Pizza sauce
  • Cheese
  • Toppings like pepperoni, olives, or bell peppers

How to make them:

  1. Preheat oven to 375F.
  2. Spread sauce on your pizza bases.
  3. Add cheese and use toppings to create an “X marks the spot” design.
  4. You can also arrange pepperoni slices to look like islands on a map.
  5. Bake in the oven at 375F for about 10 minutes. (May need more or less time depending on your oven)

These tasty maps are sure to lead to happy little pirates.





7. ???? Captain’s Catch (Fish & Chips)

Even landlubbers will love this classic pirate fare.

What you need:

  • Fish sticks or battered fish pieces
  • French fries or potato wedges

Serving tip: Arrange the fish and chips in paper cones or small baskets for that authentic “fresh from the ship’s galley” feel.





8. ???? Fruit Swords

Fruit swords (aka fruit skewers)

En garde! These fruit skewers are a fun way to get kids to eat some fruit.

Just be careful because we always tell our kids not to run around with sticks, and here we’re giving them sharp sticks, so save this for an appropriate age group (and guests) that can safely eat these.

What you need:

  • Various fruits (strawberries, grapes, pineapple chunks, watermelon cubes, etc.)
  • Plastic pirate sword picks or even just wooden skewers.

How to make them:

  1. Wash and cut your chosen fruits into bite-sized pieces.
  2. Carefully thread the fruit onto the plastic sword picks or wooden skewers.

These colorful swords are a great way to get some healthy options into your pirate feast!


With these 8 pirate-themed food ideas, your child’s birthday party is sure to be memorable and fun.

Remember, the key to a great party is having fun, so don’t stress if things aren’t perfect. Your little pirates will be too busy enjoying the adventure to notice!

So prepare the galley, get your pirate hat on and get ready for a party that they’ll remember for years.

Enjoy.



You May Also Like:

Pirate birthday party ideas for kids

If you’re having a pirate party for your kids, you’ll want to check out these ideas.



basketball birthday party ideas for kids

Does your little one love basketball? If so, check out these basketball birthday party ideas!